Then the 49ers would have a legitimate quarterback controversy, and a welcome one at that. Whether they decide that or not, there are going to be a lot of tempting options out there for them to at least consider. If any of those squads lands Garoppolo and he can put together a healthy season or two in the years to come, it won't regret taking a shot at one of the most underappreciated free agents the league has ever seen. In terms of . In the right offense, with an adept offensive coach capable of utilizing his skill set the way guys like Josh McDaniels and Kyle Shanahan have, it's clear Garoppolo has the ability to start for a Super Bowl team. Backup C.J. 12 pick as well as first and third-round choices in 2022 . San Francisco 49ers quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo (10) drops back to pass against the Kansas City Chiefs in . Without the quarterback in the lineup, San Francisco is 7-26. There's one more sign pointing to Jimmy Garoppolo's exit from San Francisco. The Niners have undoubtedly fared better with Garoppolo than without him. But quarterbacks who can carry rarely get near the open market. If that answer sounds similar to the one Shanahan gave almost every time he was asked the question before, it's because it is. What Purdy did wasnt mystical or magical. NFL insider Adam Schefter explains why San Francisco would stick with Jimmy G., but also how they would not. Well, this is projecting a bit because the 49ers do like Jimmy G,Fowler explained onSportsCenter. "You look into every avenue and you see if there's something out there that can get you a ton better," Shanahan said. . General manager John Lynch and Shanahan got permission from 49ers ownership to carry Garoppolo and Lance's salaries this year (an estimated $32.6 million in cap space) before trading up for the third pick. All Rights Reserved. There are certainly Jimmy Gs limitations, and the total chatter about San Francisco offboarding its starting quarterback this offseason has plenty of merits. "It'd be very hard for me to picture a situation where Jimmy's not here," Shanahan said. Perhaps it won't happen until 2022. Now that San Francisco has confirmed that Garoppolo is all but gone, attention in Northern California turns to injured . But he actually ranked at or well above the qualified median in that metric in his previous two relatively full NFL seasons. So we'll play that [quarterback competition] by ear, but I expect Jimmy to be here and I'd be surprised if he wasn't. 2023 Minute Media - All Rights Reserved. All advice, including picks and predictions, is based on individual commentators opinions and not that of Minute Media or its related brands. 10-wearing QB, Jimmy Garoppolo, NFL.com names free-agent fit for 49ers, potential landing spots for McGlinchey, Al-Shaair, Why 49ers' Nick Bosa believes he has the "hardest job in America", 49ers DE Drake Jackson has to take a big step in Year 2. The 49ers at that point had no idea what they had in Purdy. The San Francisco 49ers were 7-26 without Jimmy Garoppolo between the 2017 and 2020 seasons. While the 49ers are set to close out the season in the divisional matchup against the Seattle Seahawks, the team isn't guaranteeing the quarterback's 2020 return. SANTA CLARA (AP) Jimmy Garoppolo's playoff performance is all anyone would need to understand the decisions the San Francisco 49ers made last . Getty We admire the teammate that he was, so I know everyone wants to talk about some discourse and all that, but I do believe that its probably run its course, but I think we leave with nothing but fond memories of Jimmy and Jimmys going to go play good football for someone.. Head coach Kyle Shanahan already stated that he can't envision a scenario where Garoppolo returns for a seventh season with the team. Garoppolo has not played a game since and the 49ers made a franchise-altering trade with the Miami Dolphins on March 26, sending the No. Who has the most career 300 passing yard games? Will the Dolphins get a veteran QB? He seemed to connect with his teammates and there are no red flags concerning his character. Without Jimmy G, the 49ers have been worse than the Jets. That started in January when the team was linked to Matthew Stafford before their divisional. From offseason hires to positional needs, here are four things we learned about the Arizona Cardinals from team reporter Dani Sureck on the 49ers "You've Got Mail" podcast presented by Manscaped. If they arent able to make a trade, they should just put him on season long injured reserve and let Mullens play out the next eight games. He'll likely be highly sought by quarterback-needy teams. Garoppolo, who will turn 30 next season, has struggled to stay healthy over his four years in the Bay Area, missing a total of 33 games. Even if there was a suitor, the Niners would need Garoppolo's approval because of his no-trade clause. On a recent episode of NFL Total Access, analyst Michael Robinson suggested that the Carolina Panthers allow Sam Darnold to walk and replace him with Jimmy Garoppolo. As the 2020 regular NFL season comes to an end more speculation on whether or not the 49ers are going to keep Jimmy Garoppolo heats up. "We made this move, it's obvious what I hope and what I believe in with this guy coming in," Shanahan said of Lance. The Raiders come to mind considering the talent they have entering the post-Carr era; the Tampa Bay Buccaneers make sense as they look to remain contenders following Tom Brady's latest retirement; and the New Orleans Saints, New York Jets and Washington Commanders all had top-10 defenses in terms of DVOA (defense-adjusted value over average) at Football Outsiders but were handcuffed by poor and/or inconsistent quarterback play in 2022. Purdy provided nothing but answers in his whirlwind nine-game stretch beginning with a relief performance against Miami after Jimmy Garoppolo left with a broken foot. That is why the 49ers need to make the move now. At the same time, Shanahan certainly understands his other Niners quarterbacks aside from Jimmy G havent had anything close to the kind of success one would require to be a playoff contender. Is Mullens going to be the long-term answer? Your favorite teams, topics, and players all on your favorite mobile devices. As the 2020 regular NFL season comes to an end, more speculation . I think that theyll look at Jimmy, Schefter continued. "In our first year, at the end of the year, we do a, It's NFL Combine week, and the San Francisco 49ers are well into the offseason. Come February 2022, if not sooner, he is gone. But if they feel that the injuries are just too much to handle and they need to move on, Ive talked to many coaches and coordinators around the league who believe Kyle Shanahan, one of the brilliant offensive minds in the game, should go all out on a young, athletic QB instead of going the veteran route, trading for a Kirk Cousins or a Matt Ryan. In five quarters against Miami and Seattle, Garoppolo threw three interceptions, and zero touchdowns for only 161 yards and a quarterback rating of 29.99. In his first, and only, full season as an NFL starter, he led San Francisco to a 13-win Super Bowl run in 2019. NFL Nation: Analysis for every pick The Patriots traded Garoppolo to the 49ers in 2017. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. section: | slug: 49ers-gm-john-lynch-says-he-contacted-tom-brady-as-san-francisco-may-add-qb-help-for-2023 | sport: football | route: article_single.us | The New England Patriots and Chicago Bears, two logical landing spots before the draft, selected quarterbacks in the first round. "We arrived at a point where that was our preference to draft a quarterback and keep Jimmy," Lynch said. General manager John Lynch joked about the possibility Wednesday, telling reporters he contacted Brady after his recent retirement, and that San Francisco may add a veteran QB this offseason. There was an expectation hed be traded last season, but a shoulder injury derailed those plans, so he restructured his contract to stay with the club for one more season. Despite his success, 49er fans have come to expect at. That record breaks a team. . The Denver Broncos traded for veteran Teddy Bridgewater to go with Drew Lock. With both Brock Purdy and Trey Lance coming off injury, they could rotate QBs once again in 2023. For those who want to point to his record, yes, it is very good, but you need to take a look at who Garoppolo is now. 3 overall in 2021 and take Lance is a decision which can pay dividends with a dual-threat quarterback of the future. Health permitting, theres no reason to believe he wont do it again with the same coach, the same offense, the same weapons and a top-flight defense to get him the ball. "Start for," not "carry." Player and team photos used with permission from. Yesterday against Seattle, this was on full display. He's 31 years old and in the midst of what is likely his prime, his teams are 40-17 when he serves as the starting quarterback and he's coming off an excellent season. Who had the most wins as a favorite last season? We better have a very good answer if you're going to find something better than that because Jimmy has shown in one year that he's the guy who can take us to the Super Bowl and I also think that Jimmy is going to get a lot better the more he plays.". If that rookie quarterback pans out, of course. McShay's favorite pick for all 32 teams Since joining San Francisco, the 49ers own a 22-8 record with Garoppolo as the starter (24-9 including the postseason). Kyle Shanahan and the SF 49ers could move on from Jimmy Garoppolo in 2021. Which team has won the most Super Bowls? with the team finishing its 2022 campaign with an 8-9 record, good enough for third place in the AFC East. But I'm not sure we're appreciating just how efficient and reliable Garoppolo has been when healthy. Right now, the difference between Garoppolo and Mullens is as thin as the paper their contracts are written on. 1 pick, 49ers figuring out how to take next step in Super Bowl quest, Ideal landing spots for the NFL's top 50 free agents: Here's where each player fits best, From Baroque to the big game: The fine art of the NFL playoffs, Where could Derek Carr land now? Without the quarterback in the lineup, San Francisco is 7-26. The curse of the almost-good quarterback is one of the worst things that an NFL team can be affected with. The content on this site is for entertainment and educational purposes only. Stroud, Will Levis and Anthony Richardson, and because players like Carr, Rodgers and Jackson are/could become available and have bigger names and longer resumes, it's entirely possible Garoppolo will continue to receive less attention than his own resume indicates he's worth come the start of free agency. Head coach Kyle Shanahan was already clear in saying he didnt see a scenario where the veteran quarterback would be back with the 49ers for a seventh season. The use of any team names, words, trademarks, logos or photos have been used for descriptive purposes only. After running through NFC Playoffs, the 49ers surged to a 10 point fourth quarter lead against the Kansas City Chiefs in the Super Bowl. In 2019, Shanahan led the 49ers to a 13-3 record and the number 1 seed in the NFC. "I sent him a text when he retired," Lynch said of Brady, per the Tampa Bay Times. Yet, it. One ESPN reporter named two potential fits for the veteran quarterback (h/t Chris Rosvoglou of The Spun). Scouting reports | More draft coverage. All picks and predictions are suggestions only. 49ers QB rumors: Are Patriots fans hoping for a Jimmy Garoppolo reunion? Just yesterday we saw Mullens come in and get the ball out quick to receivers on short routes that Garoppolo has missed throws on regularly in recent weeks. For what it's worth, the 49ers don't believe Lance is as far away as outside perception would lead you to believe. Still, the stark contrast between games in which Garoppolo has started compared to games where he hasnt is awfully telling. For those thinking Shanahan is a quarterback mastermind who can turn any modest signal-caller into a workable commodity in his offense, the bottom line says otherwise. Growing up a 49ers fan, the longtime Patriots star was alsobriefly on Lynch's radar in 2020, when Brady tested free agency and ultimately landed with the Buccaneers. But that doesn't mean he's just a custodian, either. For every Mahomes out there, theres easily a Mitchell Trubisky of the Chicago Bears. Lance told Lynch after the Niners drafted him, Garoppolo was one of the first people to reach out. ESPN Enterprises, Inc. All rights reserved. Injuries have caused him to miss significant time in three of his five full seasons with the San Francisco 49ers, and in another of those campaigns he played through a major injury to his throwing . Trading Garoppolo would also mean the 49ers need a better veteran option at backup behind Lance. Catch up on the latest San Francisco 49ers headlines, powered by Cisco. Aaron Rodgers, Derek Carr and others are stealing the offseason spotlight from Jimmy Garoppolo. While it would be hard for the Niners to move on from the 28-year-old signal-caller, its not impossible. He graduated from San Jose State University with a BA degree in journalism. For the first time since the game against Miami, Kyle Shanahan asked Garoppolo to help carry the load a bit and, just like he did against Miami, everyone saw him unable to do so. former Super Bowl winning NFL head coach and father of current 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan, Chicago Bears . So why is nobody talking about Jimmy Garoppolo? Jimmy Garoppolo is 39-18 with the 49ers in his career. A new home for Michael Thomas? While the quartrtback position also falls into that category, the 49ers appear content with Garoppolo remaining under center in 2021. Based on the last two seasons, when the 49ers started 3-5 and 3-4 and made the playoffs both times, an early in-season Lance bellyflop wouldnt be detrimental so long as Purdy can take over. Theres one more sign pointing to Jimmy Garoppolos exit from San Francisco. Jimmy Garoppolo QB #10 Experience: 9 years. It also presents an opportunity for Trey Lance, the presumptive starter a year ago at this time, and hes got a small window to assert himself. We still dont know. All of which might make it easy to forget that the NFC's highest-rated qualified passer from the 2022 season will become a free agent on March 15. Garoppolo doesn't put up gaudy numbers but the 49ers win while he is under center, his record is 31-14 as the starter for the 49ers. So, theyve been pretty good with him, and if they were going to move on, I think it would take some sort of compelling option, whatever that would be, and those are not easy to come by. All betting content is intended for an audience ages 21+. In fact, we're talking about the sixth-highest-rated qualified passer in NFL history. NFL Nation: Analysis for every pick 10 teams that could have interest, and how much cash he could get. From a purely statistical perspective, Mullens is 1-1 in his two starts and is actually playing better. It could be in the coming months after the Niners get a closer look at Lance. Well, its a quarterback, and its a quarterback on a good team, Schefter explained on the Murph & Mac show, so youre always curious as to how thats going to work out. Who is the all . He has to get out there and play. But theres one telling stat that jumps out when looking at Shanahan and the SF 49ers with Garoppolo under center compared to when hes not there: the record. Despite the San Francisco 49ers' rush to move on from the 31-year-old QB, Jimmy G is 40 . None of this is a knock on Lance. It happened, it was real, and it was evident the first time he played in a game that really mattered when he stared down repeated heavy blitzes against Miami. Both quarterbacks are slated to become unrestricted free agents on March 15. But until the doctors give us the go, we're not going to.". Garoppolo has not played a game since and the 49ers made a franchise-altering trade with the Miami Dolphins on March 26, sending the No. Could Shanahan trade for an established veteran, perhaps the Detroit Lions Matthew Stafford or the Atlanta Falcons Matt Ryan? 49ers will get chance to fully evaluate Trey Lance with Brock Purdy rehabbing right elbow into late-August, September. The San Francisco 49ers have a record of 7-19 without Jimmy Garoppolo since 2018. beginning with a relief performance against Miami after Jimmy Garoppolo . Elite level coaches have proven that they can win games and even make playoff runs . Garoppolo's future came into question after the quarterback was sidelined to injury for the majority of the 49ers uninspiring season. Won two playoff games. Whether Garoppolo strings along an inspiring and healthy, series of practices over the next few days, the signs, and Shanahan, are trending towards a 2021 season return for the quarterback. - San Francisco 49ers Blog- ESPN Skip to main content Skip to navigation Full Scoreboard ESPN Search NFL Home Draft Scores. Jimmy Garoppolo, Nick Bosa, Trent Williams and Dre Greenlaw discussed the team's week of practices in Colorado, previewed the 49ers Week 11 matchup against the Arizona Cardinals and praised the . Ron Borges Jan 20, 2022 11:59 PM EST All he does is win, and he does it a lot. They have a 24-9 record (including playoffs) with him as the starter, while going 5-23 in all other games under Shanahan without him as the starter. Or the Niners look to the draft to grab a rookie to sit behind Jimmy G.. Jimmy Garoppolo? Yes, Garoppolo can be fragile. It doesn't appear that's going to change anytime soon. In fact, last season they were offered a chance at taking future Hall of Fame QB Tom Brady, but they decided against it, most likely because Jimmy G. has a lot more left in him than Brady who is en route to retirement. Follow theHeavy on 49ers Facebook pagefor the latest breaking news, rumors and content! We picked bold, outside-the-box moves for every NFL team, Montana SB jersey breaks Brady's auction record, 49ers All-Pro Nick Bosa will 'break the entire bank,' but it might take time, Predicting the 2023 starting QB for all 32 NFL teams, from the locks to the wild cards, A new home for Michael Thomas? Fewest games to 10,000 passing yards with the. Here's why it's time for the San Francisco 49ers to move on from Jimmy Garoppolo. NFL Insider Can Envision 49ers Without Jimmy Garoppolo in 2021. Between the draft, free agency, and trade options, the 49ers might find themselves in a position to want to reconsider. The curse of the almost-good quarterback is one of the worst things that an NFL team can be affected with. San Francisco might move on from Garoppolo this offseason. NAME GP REC W% CMP ATT PCT YDS . Brian Hoyer flamed out after six losses, C.J. One of the most notable, though not surprising, things that Lynch said was something about Trey Lance. Jimmy Garoppolo's facial expressions irked NFL fans on Sunday as his 49ers got blown out by the Eagles, 31-7, in this year's NFC Championship game. . Purdy was a revelation off the bench late in 2022, showcasing veteran-level poise in a 7-1 run as starter, but he's facing an ambiguous timetable for recovery from elbow surgery. Or if they made a bad decision and then got incredibly lucky with their final pick in 2022 to cover for their mistake. In addition, Mullens was able to hit a deep shot to Brandon Aiyuk and stare down the barrel of a few Seahawks blitzes to hit the receivers for nice gains. "Because that would be, I think, very stressful for us, because Jimmy's a very good player and I think we can win with him. "I know this coaching staff and the guys in the quarterback room are going to push me and help me compete and help me learn," Lance said. Fans . SANTA CLARA, Calif. -- By the time the San Francisco 49ers drafted Trey Lance as their future franchise quarterback with the No. Head coach Kyle Shanahan was already clear in saying he didn't . This offseason offers a deep pool of available options at quarterback through the draft and free agency. And no, he doesn't have a rocket launcher for an arm. When Jimmy Garoppolo is available as a starter, San. Who is the all-time NFL passing leader? Injuries have caused him to miss significant time in three of his five full seasons with the San Francisco 49ers, and in another of those campaigns he played through a major injury to his throwing hand. The 49ers are more familiar with the quarterback shuffle than most. He is there for the Patriots' taking . 12 pick as well as first and third-round choices in 2022 and a first-round selection in 2023 in exchange for the No. In the meantime, not leaving the football world's peripheral vision are up-in-the-air quarterbacks Lamar Jackson, Aaron Rodgers and Derek Carr. January 30, 2023 11:35am. Explore Who is the all-time passing leader for the 49ers? With the exception of one half against the New York Jets, Garoppolo has looked like anything but a quarterback that is worth taking up more than an eighth of the 49ers salary cap. What team had the best over/under record last year? And in general, quarterback wins are a silly stat. Look where he's at financially. The projected 2021 cap figure is estimated to be right around $176 million and the 49ers currently find themselves just $8 million under that total with only 37 players under contract. And Garoppolo did rank well below the league median (3.7) with an average of 3.2 completed air yards per pass attempt in 2022. His 67.5 completion percentage ranks first in franchise history and his passer rating ranks second only behind Steve Young. . When asked whether Garoppolo would still be on the team the day after the draft ended, Shanahan said, "I can't guarantee that anybody in the world will be alive Sunday, so I can't guarantee who will be on our roster.". Despite the quarterback's injury woes, Shanahan trusts that, when healthy, Garoppolo is the best option for San Francisco going forward. The following browsers are supported: Chrome, Edge (v80 and later), Firefox and Safari. Teams do move on from good quarterbacks to take a flier on someone potentially better. Unless the Niners find themselves in a cap crunch -- they have about $18.3 million in cap room before signing the rookie class, according to OverTheCap -- or have an opportunity to acquire a high-cost player they can't resist, restructuring Garoppolo's contract won't be financially driven. (Almost) all he does is win, mainly because he (almost) never makes killer mistakes. At the same time, though, Garoppolo has given the one thing Shanahan hasnt gotten with anyone else over three-plus years: wins. 12 spot in the NFL draft order. The content and information from other sites is the property of their respective owners. Robinson believes Garoppolo is what one such team, the Panthers, If it wasn't clear by head coach Kyle Shanahan's comments on February 1 that the Jimmy Garoppolo era with the San Francisco 49ers was over, general manager John Lynch made it clear today. It's unlikely to be back with the San Francisco 49ers. No one should expect to make money from the picks and predictions discussed on this website. He suffered multiple high-ankle sprains that kept him out of the lineup for nearly three quarters of the season. Naturally, that trade again cast doubt on Garoppolo's future in San Francisco, which reached fever pitch on April 26 when Shanahan bungled what was meant to be a playful interaction with a reporter. Here are their options. General manager John Lynch hit the right notes Tuesday while addressing Brock Purdys status at the NFL Scouting Combine in Indianapolis. What will define Eric Bieniemy's success? With Tom Brady retired, what are the Buccaneers' QB options? It improved the 49ers' record to 5-4, a half-game behind Seattle in the . Beathard was a third-round disappointment, and Nick Mullens has shown nothing more than being capable of serving as a modest backup at best. The 49ers, with a 5-9 record, currently own the No. Having a quarterback like Garoppolo take up $25.5 million makes the situation untenable. Start a rebuild? 49ers is a registered trademark of the Forty Niners Football Company LLC. 3 pick in this year's draft. He wont be deterred by a late start. Won Shanahans trust in a way that Garoppolo never did. ESPNs Jeremy Fowler feels it would only make sense to go younger and it wouldnt be such a bad choice when looking at this years 2021 draft class stacked with top QBs featuring Floridas Kyle Trask or BYUs Zach Wilson. Kyle Shanahan Tells Robert Saleh He Cant Take 49ers Coaches With Him. What the 49ers arent saying publicly is that having Purdy rehabbing and on the sidelines into late August and into September isnt necessarily a bad thing in terms of 2023 and beyond. Jimmy, you can win with. If San Francisco goes with Alabama's Mac Jones, the sentiment is that the 49ers will likely walk away from Garoppolo's $26.4 million cap hit with just $2.8 million in dead money on the books . That gives the 49ers a chance to assess whether their decision to part with two first-round picks and a third-round pick in order to move up to No. The 2014 second-round pick actually owns the highest qualified yards-per-attempt average in modern NFL history. 1,104: 1,632: 67.6: 13,599: 8.3: 238.6: 82: 5.0: 42: 2.6: 115: 769: 99.2: Explore. After Garoppolo took over as the starter, the 49ers won five consecutive games to close out the season. "First of all, with Jimmy, Jimmy has been tremendous for us," Lynch said. 2 min read. 2004-2023 CBS Interactive. San Francisco 49ers news fromFanSided Daily, SF 49ers free agency: Re-signing Richard Sherman doesnt make sense, SF 49ers: Ranking top 5 needs in 2021 NFL Draft, SF 49ers: Kyle Shanahan hints he'd be open to mobile quarterbacks, Larry Fitzgerald Redid His Will After Contracting Coronavirus, SF 49ers: 5 players who could be surprise cuts this offseason, SF 49ers need Jimmy Garoppolo, George Kittle for a playoff run, SF 49ers NFL Draft: 6 quarterbacks to target who aren't Zach Wilson. Jimmy Garoppolo is 39-18 with the 49ers in his career. Brady left New England after the 2019 season. Perhaps in the case of Garoppolo, Shanahan and the SF 49ers, its the proverbial devil you know.. Such options aren't exactly abundant and a quarterback room consisting of Lance, Nate Sudfeld and Josh Rosen or Josh Johnson would be a massive step down in experience from the Garoppolo, Nick Mullens, C.J.