Limits are subject to change from year to year, so please defer to IRS guidelines for current limits. Betterment interview details in New York City, NY: 37 interview questions and 35 interview reviews posted anonymously by Betterment interview candidates. Some of the topics that came up were - implementing a http endpoint, writing code to make a rspec pass, active record operations. To do good data work today, you need to use a system that is reproducible, versionable, scalable, and open. By hosting meetups for Women Who Code, a non-profit organization that empowers women through technology, were working to engage this community directly. One problem was purely coding while the other involved system design on the whiteboard. The second area we wanted to stub out was the network. Phone interview was a typical phone screening some personal questions to make sure your experience matches the role. How did I go from creating avatars with Pikachu ears to improving detection of financial criminals? At Betterment, we define CD as the process of making every small change to our system shippable as soon as its been built and tested. It leaves the variable name in plain-text while only encrypting the secret value itself and supports YAML, JSON, or binary format. And this bounty of information helps a lot if the engineer has multiple PRs open and needs to quickly switch context. You may be thinking, isnt this a simple math problem? Within the boundaries of that principle, we considered multiple interview formats, including take-home and online assessments, and several variations of pair programming interviews. And how does running millions of them per day help us? Such linked websites are not monitored, investigated, or checked for accuracy or completeness by Betterment. The main recurring issue was that hiring managers were left uncertain as to whether a candidate truly possessed the technical aptitude and skills to justify making them an employment offer. talked about the company and the role. The variables were solving for are put into a single list. With integration testing being a key level of the testing pyramid, we needed to find a way to test how features in our app interacted without the overhead involved with setting up UI tests. Consider a controller that links attachments to a given document. Fidel Severino: The opportunity to join Betterments Apprenticeship program came via the Flatiron School. Do's and Don'ts for Software Engineer Job Interview - DZone The interview process was smooth and prompt. Lets say that his Roth IRA holds $2,750 of VTI, and $2,750 of VWOB. Automatically Detecting Vulnerabilities At Betterment, we strive to make it easy for engineers to do the right thing especially when it comes to security practices. With that, weve been able to test the integration of all the components for a given flow, all written in widget-test-like style without needing to build out the entire app. First, we needed to decide what pieces of code we were interested in testing and which parts we were fine with stubbing. Any error budget we set should account for our fiduciary responsibilities, and should guarantee that we do not cause an irresponsible impact to our customers. We're building an investing platform that's one of the first of its kind. Now that weve wrangled our CI process and encoded the best practices into a tool, were ready to tackle our Continuous Deployment pipeline. The second of these issues was that the cop prevented usages ofrawandhtmlsafe, but did not prevent usages ofsafeconcat. This is a rails specific interview, where you get a rails app and you go through it fixing and creating features. If we used a research-first approach to build RetireGuide, the result could have been a planning tool that was mathematically sound but hard for our customers to use. Im Jesse, a recruiter here at Betterment, and I had the immense pleasure of working closely with these two. We arent getting rid of all the JavaScript in our application. What are "end-to-end-ish" tests? For that, our app has a thin wrapper around the http package called HttpClient. If we arent alerting on those 3 hours of errors, and instead just once if we exceed that limit, then we can direct our attention toward new product features, platform improvements, or learning and development. To avoid time-consuming manual processes, and the human error typical of that approach, analytics has become a programming discipline. While most of this transition was smooth, there were a few cases where legacy code slowed our progress. The challenge becomes: how do we replicate the integration environment without the integration environment? We then moved into a coding problem that involved writing classes to model data and logic to query that data to answer increasingly complex questions. I moved to New York after getting an opportunity at Sony and worked for a year producing video content. It is notoriously hard to estimate the complexity of a task when it needs to be built into or on top of a legacy system. model initialization, find calls, etc). For this problem, we made our initial guess to be what each store had in stock, and we supplied it to the minimize method as a list. Instead of simply instructing and watching candidates as they program, interviewers can now work with them on a real-world problem, and they take turns in control of the keyboard. While we may implement a hot-standby backup in the future, we simply accept it as a known risk and set our monitoring system to notify a team member of any deviances. Modifying our integration with SimonData in order to bulk update our outgoing emails, and Changing how we share a users name with our customer service (CX) team through a Zendesk integration, as well as in our internal CX application. At Betterment, staying compliant with regulators, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission, is a part of everyday life. Specifically, well want to make our jobs idempotentbasically, safely retryable, or resumableand that is on us as application developers to ensure on a case-by-case basis. Fortunately, Airflow already maintains a wide selection ofhooksto work with remote sources such as S3. Tell me about a time you collaborated at work. Betterment was super supportive and accommodating. Given the formulaic patterns of these bugs, we decided static analysis would be a worthwhile endeavor. I interviewed at Betterment (New York, NY). This forces extra thought and extra conversation in code review to ensure that the usage is in fact safe. If there is significant conditional behavior in the view layer and you are looking to make your system spec leaner, you may want to extract that conditional behavior to a presenter resource model and test that separately in a model spec so that you dont need to worry about testing it in a system spec. Its definitely the case that a team might not be at the level of operational maturity where defining product or user-specific service level objectives is in the cards. Be the first to find this interview helpful, Get started with your Free Employer Profile. To answer that question, Ill leave you with one last takeaway. We not only had unit tests such as the one above to test simple scenarios where a human could calculate the outcome, but we also ran the optimizer in a simulated production-like environment, through hundreds of thousands of scenarios that closely resembled real ones. How is pay, wlb & work culture. All it took was 1 week. This means that application developers need to consider authorization with every controller we write or change. Coachwas designed and built with these principles: Standardize the pipelinethere should be one way to test code, and one way to deploy it Test code oftencode should be tested as often as its committed Build artifacts oftencode should be built as often as its tested so that it can be deployed at any time Be environment agnosticartifacts should be built in an environment-agnostic way with maximum portability Give consistent feedbackthe CI output should be consistent no matter the language runtime Shorten the feedback loopengineers should receive actionable feedback as soon as possible Standardizing CI was critical to our growth as an organization for a number of reasons. However, TCP brought a new level of complexity that required us to rethink the way parts of our trading system were built. Working with our product team, we determined that the minimum amount of change to consider a page rebranded was adoption of the new header, footer, colors, and fonts. More critically, the one-off script solution wasnt stored in source control, therefore it wasnt tested. Aside from partials, there was corresponding styling, or CSS, that was being copied and sometimes changed when these shared partials were altered. INSTEAD OF THIS: Post.find(params[:post_id]) DO THIS: currentuser.posts.find(params[:postid]) See here for more information on this error: https://github.com/Betterment/betterlint/blob/main/README.md#bettermentunscopedfind @document = Document.find(params[:document_id]) ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ 1 file inspected, 1 offense detected The cop successfully located the vulnerability. HR screen followed by a technical phone screen and final round. Cassidy Williams, Venmo engineer, said impostor syndrome tends to be more common in high-achieving women. This allows us to continue composing a UI with self contained building blocks. Its a constant battle to keep things maintainable, readable, testable, and efficient. If our service didnt succeed at that goal, the violation overflow called an error budget shows us by how much we fell short. We were able to do this by having our app widget that handles dependency setup take a child, then pumping the app widget wrapped around whatever feature widget we wanted to test. Easy and comprehensive testing. In order to avoid test inter-dependency issues, we can instead run our tests in a random order (per file) by passing the --test-randomize-ordering-seed flag to flutter test. Before I began my internship, I had never worked on a Web app before. Instead, each worker acts independently. To incorporate a third-party solver into our system, we built a translation layer that received our system-generated constraints and objective function as inputs, and utilized those inputs to solve the model using a third-party API. Search. Centralizing architectural decision-making would kill ownership and autonomy, and ensure your best people leave or never join in the first place. Optimal Testing Because we use these three different categories of specs, its important to keep in mind what each type of spec is for to avoid over-testing. Whats the best way to have a lack of compensation and incentive conversation in your department? They showed me how we were getting quite a few requests from trans customers to quit deadnaming them. Plenty of jobs may complete in failure, or simply fail to complete, and may require some form of automated or manual intervention. Williams goal is to help women recognize the characteristic and empower them to overcome it. Using the JavaScript single page app framework, we would need a few things. It is a historical archive and is not intended to be updated. If youve read this far, wed encourage you to take the leap and test out the delayed gem for yourself! A recruiter followed up within two days and we did a call to discuss qualifications. The solution we came up with is called charlatan and it's open-source and available on pub.dev. So if you can encrypt them safely, you can ship your secrets with your code and have a single change management workflow. Fidel Severino: While working, I would take any available time for courses on websites like Codecademy and Team Treehouse. Where are we authorizing the users access to those parameters? After that there was a first round interviews with 2 software engineers and 1 manager totaling about 2.5 hours. Companies should strive for a fair balance between adding new features and refactoring legacy code, and should establish a culture where thoughtful code design is a priority. Im going to walk you through how we got there. What are some specific ways in which companies can contribute to these movements and promote a healthier and more inclusive work culture? As we stated in our requirements for Coach in the first post, we believe there should be one way to test code, and one way to deploy it. Airflowqueuesallow us to designate certain tasks to run on particular hardware (e.g. But once we looked under the surface, #firstname was sprinkled nearly everywhere in our codebase. It starts with our users - Betterment users - and trying to provide them with a certain quality of service. If theyre in our codebase, we should be able to iterate on the fakes without having to restart our server; the behavior isnt always right the first time, and restarting is tedious and it's not the Rails Way. To solve this problem, we developed WebValvea tool that allows us to define and register fake implementations of HTTP services and toggle between real and fake services in non-production environments. Legacy workloads that are complex and underperforming can now be transitioned over to the data warehouse schema incrementally. Our team is passionate about our mission: making people's lives better. Writing end-to-end tests is pretty expensive. Our Principles in Action: Shortening the FeedbackLoop The feedback loop in the Old World run by Jenkins was one of the biggest hurdles to overcome. Think of something like Heroku, but for engineers here at Betterment. Some javascript questions about scoping and how to build an app. Company Executive1:1 on your background and the company. As of July 2016, all full-stack, mobile, and site-reliability engineering roles have adopted this new approach. Weve been using these cops for over a year now and have had a lot of success with them. It also showed how an asset allocation would perform over the lifetime of an investment. Because its in source control and it runs through its own CI process, we can also easily roll out changes to notifications without breaking things. Weve usedUJSsprinkles in similar fashion to the rest of the Rails world over the years, but that has its limitations as we begin to design more complex behaviors and elements of our apps. It's not quite the interactive experience of the Datadog UI, but it's fairly straightforward to fiddle in the UI and then extract the resulting configuration and add it to our config file. It might take some time to convince the rest of your organization to receive reports in these more modern formats. Colorado: $175,000 - $190,000. Building out the user interface. Analysis, Model Building, Learning Youll probably only present one or two of the scores of models and variants you build and test. The switch to Julia has allowed us not only to optimize and speed up our code by multiple orders of magnitude, but also has given us the environment and ecosystem to explore ideas that would simply not be possible in our previous implementations. We developed the SHARE Series to create an authentic and conversational environment, one where attendees help guide the conversations and future event themes. The last of our requirements was to be able to launch into a specific feature rather than having to navigate through the whole app. Co-founder Emily Knutsen wanted to build a network of diverse individuals and foster deeper connections among women in our community. Through the SHARE Series, we hope to empower future leaders in our industry to reach their goals and develop important professional connections. This is useful for API calls that always behave the same way, like POSTs that return no body, and to provide a working foundation of responses. Technical interview (computer science fundamentals), Technical interview (modelling and app design), Ask the candidate to describe a recent technical challenge in detail, Introduce the pair programming problem and explore the problem, Pair programming (optional, time permitting). Changing workflows and acquiring new skills is always an investment, but the dividends here are better collaboration, efficient iteration, transparency in process and confidence in the claims and recommendations you make. For example, were representing the expected value of holding VTI in your Taxable as which weve defined to be 0.07. Note that the error path and two common success paths are exercised in the same spec. Having a tool to protect ourselves from ourselves is vital to our workflow. Jesse Harrelson: Seriously though, it was the combination of all that plus so many other things. Any insights would be helpful. If I add another group named when a user is logged out, I would expect both groups to have setUp() methods that correctly create or set up the user model to have the correct authentication state. What to say when thingssucceed We didnt change the frequency of messaging for successwe got that right the first time around. In our updated portfolio, the number of possible transactions types did not change. The resulting analytical master file was still large, but small enough to fit on a regular MacBook Pro. We employed the m1.small instances, relying on the quality of quantity. Secured rank among top 15 in letsgrowmore summer of code, won first place in Diversion 2022, among top 3 mentors in . I have experience in several different backend/ frontend frameworks, yet rails has some specific quirks, and your interviewers will not help you in this regard, but will simply try to see how you figure out, so they basically force you to google mid interview, and set you on a timer. Create an input queue: We created a bucket with every simulationmore than 200,000we wanted to run. Thanks primarily to the simple addition of theLABiometryTypeenum newly available in iOS 11, its easy for our application to determine which biometry feature, if any, is available on a given device. We will also cover the custom tools weve built to help avoid these patterns before they can lead to vulnerabilities. Similarly, even our authorized endpoints never allow one user to peer into another users object graph. Recruiter was great in connecting me with more engineers and managers to get more insight onto the role and culture. Attaching to our example function with Ruby-FFI is straightforward: From here, we could begin using our function, but it wouldnt be entirely pleasant to work withconverting an input array to a pointer and processing the result would require some tedious boilerplate. 16.0availableacrossallstores. We cannot assign Joe more money than he already has, nor can we move money between his Roth IRA and taxable accounts. When a test case cares about the specifics of a response, it can override that default. I applied online. From 1 to N: Distributed Data Processing with Airflow Betterment has built a highly available data processing platform to power new product features and backend processing needs using Airflow. Several times we ran into corner cases around old users, test users, and other anomalous data that caused false positive failures in our characterization tests. While we didnt run a scientifically valid split-test for the new process versus the old (it wouldve taken years to reach statistical significance), our hiring metrics have improved across the board. To get there we had to make all of our Java apps respond to the same set of commands, and all of our Ruby apps to do the same. NDA signed. These restrictions require us to allow for some portfolio driftsome deviation from the target allocation. Secondly, its missing environment-specific behavior, which in this case, translates into the ability to toggle the library on and off and separately toggle the connection to specific collaborator services on and off. They should generally give you confidence that a particular model will do exactly what you intended it to do across a range of possible circumstances. What could happen if we dont escapecontent? Then, we configure our init system, upstart, to execute the process wrapped in the sopsorific run command. Then, we could rearrange these chunks to replicate all sorts of trading activity patterns. I applied online. By the way, this is a topic I could talk about endlessly, so Ill leave it there for now. This interactive tool was a great start, but it lives in isolation, away from the holistic Betterment experience. We valued the ability to encrypt just the secret values themselves and leave the variable name in plain-text. We cant take negative ingredients from the store, so the lower bound it always 0. Betterment is a great company to work for culture wise (as I mentioned) but unfortunately the total comp is not very competitive. 2 Technical interviews, followed by an AMA style lunch and then behavioral interviews for the rest of the day. Not only was this frustrating, but it was inefficient. Some examples: html_safe: [1] pry(main)> include ActionView::Helpers::OutputSafetyHelper => Object [2] pry(main)> result = hi.html_safe => hi [3] pry(main)> result.class => ActiveSupport::SafeBuffer raw: [1] pry(main)> result = raw(hi) => hi [2] pry(main)> result.class => ActiveSupport::SafeBuffer safe_concat: [1] pry(main)> include ActionView::Helpers::TextHelper => Object [2] pry(main)> buffer1 = hi.html_safe => hi [3] pry(main)> result = buffer1.safe_concat(bye) => hibye [4] pry(main)> result.class => ActiveSupport::SafeBuffer safe_join: [1] pry(main)> include ActionView::Helpers::OutputSafetyHelper => Object [2] pry(main)> result = safe_join([hi, bye]) =>
hi
bye
[3] pry(main)> result.class => ActiveSupport::SafeBuffer => ActiveSupport::SafeBuffer Rubocop: weresafe! Ive inquired about pay but its gotten nowhere. Working behind the scenes, the members of our Quantitative Investing team bring our customers the projections and recommendations they rely on for keeping their goals on-track. There needs to be a way to set up a new project. In other words, the following test file will always exit successfully, despite the fact that there are obvious issues with how its set up. While the nascency of Julia as a language means that the community and ecosystem is much smaller than those of other languages, we found that the code and community oversamples on the type of libraries that we care about. How we managed to actually execute on this will become clearer in the next section, but for the sake of hand-wavy-expediency, we have a way to run a few commands and distribute CI changes to every project in a matter of minutes. Instead of simply instructing and watching candidates as they program, interviewers can now work with them on a real-world problem, and they take turns in control of the keyboard. The structure of a Web app is a lot more complex than what the user sees on the page. Heres a simplified version of our upstart configuration. Therefore, to make sure we limit chicken to 40% of the overall ingredients, one element of the constraints tuple will be, {'type':'ineq', 'fun':lambdax:sum(extract_ingredient_specific_pounds(x,chicken))(calc_total_pounds_of_food(x)*.4)} Making sure the soup nazi is able to carry everything back from the store: 12a1a2a7>=0 17d1d2d7>=17 Leads to, {'type':'ineq', 'fun':lambdax:max_per_store[store]np.sum(extract_store_specific_pounds(x,store))} Hopefully this gives you enough information to make sense of the code example. 1 Betterment Junior Software Engineer interview questions and 1 interview reviews. Julia solves this issue by making it very simple to take a piece of research code and refactor it for production use. Combined together we call this aproject_type. What is a trust root chain? We could not only make good decisions for Elaine, Jerry, and Newman, we could make those decisions optimally. Commercial Customer Service Representative. . We began with thispull requestto patch the first issuechange the behavior of the cop to recognizerawandhtmlsafeas violations regardless of being wrapped insafejoin. Our team is passionate about our mission: making people's lives better. In most cases, a user transaction will eventually be the parent of several trade objects. 1 Betterment Software Engineer Internal Tools interview questions and 1 interview reviews. There are plenty of other features that weve built that havent made it into the delayed gem quite yet. Sometimes, it's a good idea to think outside the box in order to strike the right balance of test coverage, confidence, and maintainability. In this post, well explore that principle and dive into how we committed 5000 line configuration files to our repositories with confidence by standardizing CI for different runtimes, automating configuration generation in code, and testing the process that generates that configuration. Guidelines for Testing Rails Applications Discusses the different responsibilities of model, request, and system specs, and other high level guidelines for writing specs using RSpec & Capybara. Very pleasant and friendly experience. While we encourage candidates to ask questions of everyone they meet, the AMA provides an opportunity to meet with a Betterment engineer who has zero input on whether or not to hire them. As developers of financial software on the web, one of our biggest responsibilities is to keep our applications secure. Unfortunately integration_test was very similar to flutter_driver, in that it took the same UI/E2E approach, which meant that it had the same benefits and drawbacks that flutter_driver had. So stripping out all non-trading data was the key to focusing on the right things to test for this project. The umbrella term observability covers all manner of subjects, from basic telemetry to logging, to making claims about longer-term performance in the shape of service level objectives (SLOs) and occasionally service level agreements (SLAs). There was a lot for us to do. We were also feeling the classic pain points of a growing team contributing to a single application. Whatever the case may be, this shouldnt deter them from collecting data. More from Betterment: Server Javascript: A Single-Page App ToA Single-Page App Going to Work at Betterment Engineering at Betterment: Do You Have to Be a Financial Expert? Meetings thus far have included a panel discussion on breaking into tech from the corporate world and a small-group financial discussion led by financial experts from Betterment and beyond. Since one of the draws of using Julia in the first place is the performance of the code, we make sure to benchmark our code during every pull request for potential performance regressions using theBenchmarkTools.jlpackage. I applied online. Versionable Code versioning frameworks, such as git, are now a staple in the workflow of most technical teams. We believe this is important so that we can quickly tell which secrets an app is dependent on just by opening the file. We can collectively build and share a body of interrelated principles driven by insights that our industry as a whole hasnt yet realized or is just beginning to understand. We recently put some code into production that uses an optimizer to cut down on the amount of code were maintaining ourselves, and it turned out to be pretty darn cool. Ruthe Farmer - I first met Ruthe back in 2010 during my senior year of high school when I won the Illinois NCWIT Aspirations Award. To assist us in expediting this workflow, we had an alias in our bash_profiles that allowed us to run a shortcut at the command line to encrypt the secret value from our clipboard and then insert that secret value in the appropriate Ansible variables file for the appropriate environment. Now, back to the future These are just the first few bootstrapping steps. 30 min Q & A with head of recruiting - you ask questions, recruiter asks questions Does not reflect any actual portfolio and is not a guarantee of performance. Get started with your Free Employer Profile, The Ultimate Job Interview Preparation Guide. We hired Jesse Harrelson (Betterment for Advisors Team) and Fidel Severino (Retail Team) for a 90 day Apprentice Program. I thought my 5 year was going to finally show something but it did not. We cannot just assign arbitrarily large values to the decision variables due to two restrictions which cannot be violated: Joe must maintain $11,000 in his taxable account and $5,500 in his Roth IRA. (To any Java devs reading this: let us know if that interests you!) Then we can generate a fake for our "trading" collaborator service using rails generate webvalve:fake_service Trading. As our team has grown impressively from five to more than 50 engineers (and this was just in the last three years), weve significantly improved our abilities to make clearer hiring decisions, as well as shortened our total hiring timeline. As demonstrated, Rails provides some methods that mark content as safe without escaping it for us. We built a tool (Coach) to make the way that we build and test code conventional across all of our of apps, regardless of language, application owner, or business unit. Well only be notified if, over 7 days or 30 days or even longer, they exceed the target goal weve defined for our service. Each project needs a configuration definition file (coach.yml) that declares its project_type. Therefore, we can calculate our bounds with, defcalc_bounds(): bounds=[] forsinstores: foriiningredients: bounds.append((0,store_inventory[s][i])) returnbounds Guess Providing a good initial guess can go a long way in getting you to a desirable solution. We already use ACID-compliant datastores to solve these precise kinds of data persistence issues, so with the exception of really, really high volume operations (where a lot of noise and data loss canor mustbe tolerated), theres really no reason not to enqueue jobs co-transactionally with other data changes. Stay tuned. All products, services, and content obtained from a linked website are provided as is without warranty of any kind, express or implied, including, but not limited to, implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose, title, non-infringement, security, or accuracy.